Skip to main content

Increased income – the double-edged sword

With tax bands and other thresholds frozen, taxpayers should be aware of the implications of their income increasing. Increased income can mean more than facing a higher tax bill.

Higher rate taxpayers need to look at which allowances, reliefs or benefits are no longer claimable and those which are now worth claiming.

Lost reliefs

  • Marriage allowance – this is not available once the recipient spouse/civil partner becomes a higher rate taxpayer. The person who made the claim (the lower income spouse/civil partner) should now cancel it on their Government Gateway. However, one way to retain the allowance is for the recipient to make sufficient pension contributions so that their net income remains within the £50,270 basic rate threshold.
  • Child benefit – this starts to be clawed back once income hits £50,000 and is completely lost if income reaches £60,000. Within this band, each £1,000 of extra income represents a 10% loss of child benefit. The claw back is by way of a tax charge, with details declared on a self-assessment tax return. Again, pension contributions can reduce the level of income.
  • Childcare – if income exceeds a £100,000 threshold, tax-free childcare will no longer be available. Full free hour entitlement will also cease. Both must therefore be cancelled, with the tax-free childcare entitlement amended on the claimant’s Government Gateway. Pension contributions can, once again, help to remain below the threshold.

Using pension contributions

Pension contributions are more attractive once relief is at a higher rate than just the 20% basic rate. Contributions make even more sense if entitlement to marriage allowance, child benefit or childcare is preserved. Given that the personal allowance starts to be tapered away at the same point that tax-free childcare is lost, the overall cost of pension contributions where income just exceeds £100,000 can be negligible.

Tax trap

Aside from the increased rate of tax when income crosses a threshold, the savings allowance is cut in half to £500 for higher rate taxpayers. This is lost altogether once income reaches £125,140. Tax on savings can therefore increase despite the amount of savings income not changing. Investing in Individual Savings Accounts (ISAs) can mitigate the problem, as can pension contributions particularly if income is above the £50,270 threshold.

There are different childcare schemes in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland, and Scottish tax rates and thresholds differ.

For information on tax relief for private pension contributions visit the government website.

Photo by Mayukh Karmakar on Unsplash

Potential benefits from directors’ loans

Business owners could seek to earn interest on directors’ loans with little-to-no tax implications, although only patient directors willing to meet the reporting requirements will benefit.

Even though the rate of interest charged by HMRC on late tax payments is currently 6.75%, the rate charged on a beneficial loan for 2023/24 is much lower at 2.25%. Therefore, taking a company loan could be an attractive option for directors.

There will be no taxable benefit for 2023/24 if a director’s beneficial loans do not exceed £10,000 at any point throughout the year.

Company charge

The tax treatment of a director’s loan is complicated because there is also a company tax charge if the director is (very basically) also a shareholder and their company is a close company. For owner-managed companies, this will generally be the case.

  • The tax charge is at the rate of 33.75% on the amount of loan should the loan still be outstanding nine months and a day after the end of the company’s accounting period in which the loan is made.
  • However, this tax charge is refunded to the company if the loan is subsequently repaid by the director.


An opportunity

Given that high street banks are currently offering one-year fixed rate ISAs with an interest rate of around 4.2%, opportunistic directors could therefore:

  • Take a £20,000 interest-free loan from their company;
  • Invest this for one year, receiving tax-free interest of £840; and
  • Repay the £20,000 company loan.

Depending on the timing and the company’s accounting period, there might not be a tax charge on the company. Even if the tax charge is payable, it will be repaid once the company loan is refunded. The director will have a taxable benefit of £20,000 at 2.25% = £450 (pro-rata according to the days outstanding during the tax year). Even for an additional rate taxpayer, the tax cost will just be a little over £200.

The downside will be the various reporting requirements for both the director(s) and the company.

HEALTH WARNING: Please do not take the above as advice. These are the mere meandering thoughts of a sad old man. If anything you’ve read is of interest then please seek professional guidance from your accountant or tax adviser (you’ve been warned!!!!).

HMRC guidance on director’s loans can be found here.

Photo by Loic Leray on Unsplash

Childcare support extended to children over nine months

The government is extending the provision of 30 hours of free childcare for 38 weeks to now include all pre-school children over the age of nine months.

Phased introduction

The extended childcare provision will be of benefit to parents with newborns ­– or those planning a family – but parents with children currently aged one or two years old will not see the full benefit of the changes because of the phased introduction of the support:

From Free childcare extended to Amount of childcare
April 2024 Children aged two years 15 hours
September 2024 Children aged nine months to two years 15 hours
September 2025 30 hours

Children can take up their childcare place in the term after they meet the age requirement (subject to having received a code to give to the childcare provider), with terms typically beginning on 1 January, 1 April and 1 September.

To be eligible, both parents must work at least 16 hours a week at the National Minimum/Living Wage, and neither can earn more than £100,000 a year.

Challenges and shortfalls

Government-funded childcare entitlement is currently only available for a total of 1,140 hours a year, which works out to 30 hours over 38 weeks, so the new rules may spur some adjustments by children providers.

  • Providers may simply offer fewer hours a week to stretch the funded hours over the whole year; or
  • They may provide 30 hours for the whole year with parents paying for the shortfall of unfunded hours.

In theory, the changes will help parents who want to go back to work but finding an available childcare space will likely continue to be problematic, even with the September 2023 child-to-staff ratio increase from four to five. Many nurseries are encountering financial difficulties, and the childcare extension will mean providers cannot make up shortfalls by charging more for younger children.

There are different schemes in Scotland, Wales and Northern Ireland.

Government guidance on help with paying for childcare can be found here.

Photo by Gautam Arora on Unsplash

The demise of paper tax returns

More than 12 million taxpayers file self-assessment tax returns, but less than 3% do so using a paper return. Given this low demand, HMRC is reviewing the current paper filing service.

HMRC stopped sending out paper tax returns three years ago, with any taxpayer wishing to file by paper required to download a blank version of the form. That move brought a further 3% of taxpayers to the online service. HMRC has now announced that self-assessment tax returns will not be available to download for the 2022/23 tax year.

Alternatives

Subject to a limited exception, anyone who still wants to file offline will have to obtain a tax return form by phoning HMRC.

  • The limited exception is for visually impaired taxpayers and those aged 70 or over who have not previously submitted online. HMRC will continue sending them paper returns to complete.
  • As an alternative to contacting HMRC, a blank tax return can be printed using commercial software.

There are some taxpayers who, because of the complex tax calculations involved, simply cannot file online. This is the case even if commercial software is used, which means they will have to print their completed tax return and file it by post.

Online filing

HMRC has written to some 135,000 taxpayers who file on paper to encourage them to complete returns online in the future. In many cases, this may now be the most sensible option, and there is a wide range of commercial low-cost software available if anyone does not wish to use HMRC’s offering.

Filing online has two distinct advantages:

  • Not having to use the postal system when a return might be lost; HMRC will sometimes deny having received a mailed return even when there is a record of delivery.
  • An additional three months to file each year – the online filing deadline being 31 January following the tax year, rather than 31 October.


Capital gains tax (CGT)

Going somewhat in the opposite direction, HMRC has made a downloadable version of its CGT UK property return available on a four-month trial basis. The intention is that the downloadable form can be used by those taxpayers who cannot report and pay tax using the online service.

HMRC guidance on self-assessment tax returns can be found here.

Photo by Christin Hume on Unsplash

Pay attention to tax codes

Most directors and employees will already have been issued a tax code for the 2023/24 tax year, and it is important to check the figures as a very large proportion of codes will be incorrect. If you’ve been subject to an error, this could mean a future corrective tax bill.

Common errors

A tax code will typically take into account allowances, allowable expenses, taxable benefits (those not payrolled) and untaxed income, so there is plenty of scope for error.

  • Allowances: The code can often assume the incorrect level of income when it comes to the amount of available personal allowance.
  • Allowable expenses: Deductions for subscriptions and professional fees will be based on what was claimed previously, yet these will invariably increase annually.
  • Taxable benefits: For most benefits, HMRC will be unaware of any changes from the previous year.
  • Untaxed income: Figures for bank and building society interest can be too high where, for example, an account has been closed.


Emergency codes

A particular problem can be the use of an emergency code. These can be applied if there is a change in circumstances, such as:

  • A new job;
  • Taking on an additional part-time job; or
  • Starting employment after being self-employed.

The emergency code is used because HMRC will often not receive the employee’s income details in time after the change. Although use of the code is temporary, it can cause a cashflow problem for the employee.

Those starting a new job should give the new employer their P45 as soon as possible. Those moving from self-employment should complete the starter checklist.

Checking and correcting codes

The easiest way a person can check and correct a tax code is by logging onto their personal tax account using their Government Gateway user ID and password. HMRC can be notified of any changes that affect the tax code, and employer details can be updated.

The starting point for checking or correcting a 2023/24 tax code can be found here.

Photo by Alexandre Debiève on Unsplash+

Planes, trains and automobiles – managing employees’ transport challenges

With strikes and cancellations affecting trains, the underground and flights, employers need to decide how they are going to treat employees who cannot get into work or are stuck overseas.

Commuting

Although inconvenient, there is generally plenty of notice when it comes to train, tube and tram strikes, and therefore the chance to make contingency plans. With hybrid and homeworking now commonplace for many offices, this will be the simple and obvious answer to discuss with employees on affected days.

Employees who are required to attend work in person may face a longer and/or more expensive journeys than normal – especially if an alternative mode of transport is required. So employers should consider offering help with some financial assistance. Some absences may be avoided by rearranging work patterns or promoting car-pooling for instance.

Stuck overseas

The treatment of employees who cannot return to work after a holiday because they are stuck overseas due to a cancelled flight is somewhat more problematic.

  • If an employee can resume work as usual while abroad then they should obviously be paid as normal. It is unrealistic, however, to expect most employees – especially if not in a senior position – to have travelled with their work laptops.
  • Assuming sufficient annual leave is available, extending a holiday may be an answer where an employee is unable to work remotely. Or the employee may be happy to take unpaid leave.
  • Although there is no requirement to otherwise pay an employee who is stranded overseas, the employer might consider treating it the same as an emergency situation and remunerating on a similar basis to other emergencies, especially if the employee is taking all reasonable steps to return home.

Employees may not be able to leave the UK for their holiday in the first place and so need to rearrange their dates. Employers do not have to agree to this, especially given short notice, but a flexible approach is advisable where possible.

The Government’s guide to holiday entitlement for employers and employees can be found here.

Photo by Lisanto 李奕良 on Unsplash

Focus on tax year-end planning

With Christmas and New Year behind us, tax year-end planning should now be on your radar.

The 2021/22 tax year will end on Tuesday 5 April. This year there is no Spring Budget and Easter arrives on 15 April, so no obstacles stand in the way of year-end tax planning. Nevertheless, the sooner you start the better, as some decisions cannot be made quickly. There are some key areas to consider.

Pensions

Making pension contributions is one of the few ways that you can receive full income tax relief and reduce your taxable income. The second benefit matters in a world where your level of taxable income can determine whether you suffer the High Income Child Benefit tax charge or retain entitlement to a full personal allowance. The end of the tax year is a good time to assess how much you can contribute as you should have a good idea of your income for the year.

Inheritance tax

Now that we know the Chancellor does not have any plans for major reform of inheritance tax (IHT), there is a stable framework on which to plan. As ever, first on the list to consider is use of your annual exemptions, such as the £3,000 annual gifts exemption. With the nil rate bands currently frozen until April 2026, it is more important than ever not to let these go to waste.

Capital gains tax

As with IHT, the Chancellor has recently clarified his plans for capital gains tax (CGT). The annual exemption, which currently allows you to realise CGT-free gains of up to £12,300 each tax year, will not be slashed, nor will the tax rates be raised to income tax levels. That has simplified the year-end planning process, as there is now no point in realising gains above your annual exemption in case there would be more tax to pay in the near future.

If you think your personal finances could benefit from year-end planning, do not wait until the last moment to seek advice from a professional. Calculations will often need data that can take time to collect, particularly on the pensions front.

Photo by Visual Stories || Micheile on Unsplash

HMRC: Upper Tribunal deems child benefit discovery assessments invalid

A discovery assessment can be made by HMRC where income, which should have been assessed, has not been assessed for tax purposes. A recent decision in an Upper Tribunal case, however, found that neither child benefit, nor the related charge, is defined as income, thereby restricting HMRC’s use of discovery assessments to collect underpaid tax.

The high income child benefit charge (HICBC) applies to anyone who receives child benefit when their income, or their partner’s income, exceeds £50,000. Many have been caught out thinking the charge doesn’t apply to them or because they are unaware of their partner’s finances.

Individuals who pay tax under PAYE may never have needed to fill in a tax return. However, they are required to do so just to report the HICBC.

The decision

Jason Wilkes owed around £4,200 in unpaid taxes as a result of being subject to the HICBC for the tax years 2014/15 to 2016/17. Crucial to the decision was that Wilkes had not filed returns for these years or been issued with a notice to file.

HMRC raised discovery assessments to collect the tax due. However, since no income as such was ‘discovered’, the assessments raised were invalid.

Refunds all round?

The answer, sadly, is no. Discovery assessments are valid if tax returns have been submitted but the HICBC omitted; there is then ‘income’. This will be the case for many taxpayers.

It seems unfair that those complying with the law are at a disadvantage to those who have not. However, this is down to HMRC relying on discovery assessments rather than issuing a notice to file tax returns.

If you have been required to pay the HICBC for prior years then check to see if you fit the refund criteria: tax returns not filed, with discovery assessments used to collect the tax due.

Details of the high income child benefit charge can be found here. Let me know if you’d like to know more – or require assistance in this space.

Photo by Noble Mitchell on Unsplash

 

 

HMRC Official rate of interest, beneficial Loans et al

HMRC’s official rate of interest has been cut from 2.25% to 2% from 6 April 2021. This will affect any directors or employees who have a beneficial loan from their employer, as well as directors who have an overdrawn current account with their company. The official rate is also used in some other tax calculations.

Beneficial loans

Assuming no change to the official rate throughout 2021/22, the cut will reduce the tax payable by a higher rate taxpayer with an employer-provided interest-free loan, of, say, £50,000 from £450 to £400. Alternatively, the director or employee will need to pay interest of £1,000 rather than £1,125 for 2021/22 to avoid the tax charge.

Where an employer-provided loan is cheap rather than interest-free, the benefit charge is based on the difference between the official rate and the amount of interest actually paid. There will be no benefit if:

  • The balance of beneficial loans provided to a director or employee throughout 2021/22 does not exceed £10,000.
  • The loan is for a qualifying purpose, such as buying shares in a close company.

Directors should be particularly careful to not let an overdrawn current account go just over £10,000 at any point during the tax year.

Other uses

The official rate is also used in regard to employer-provided living accommodation and pre-owned assets tax (POAT).

  • Living accommodation – There is an additional benefit charge on the excess of the cost of the accommodation over £75,000. For example, if living accommodation cost £250,000, then the additional benefit charge for 2021/22 will be (£250,000 – £75,000) at 2% = £3,500.
  • Pre Owned Asset Tax (POAT) – There is an income tax charge on certain inheritance tax planning arrangements. Where chattels and intangible assets are concerned, the amount of deemed income subject to tax is the value of the asset multiplied by the official rate.

More detail on beneficial loans from an employer’s perspective can be found here.

Photo by Nikolay Vasiliev on Unsplash

HMRC’s April interest rate cut

HMRC’s official rate of interest has been cut from 2.25% to 2% from 6 April 2021. This will affect any directors or employees who have a beneficial loan from their employer, as well as directors who have an overdrawn current account with their company. The official rate is also used in some other tax calculations.

Beneficial loans

Assuming no change to the official rate throughout 2021/22, the cut will reduce the tax payable by a higher rate taxpayer with an employer-provided interest-free loan, of, say, £50,000 from £450 to £400. Alternatively, the director or employee will need to pay interest of £1,000 rather than £1,125 for 2021/22 to avoid the tax charge.

Where an employer-provided loan is cheap rather than interest-free, the benefit charge is based on the difference between the official rate and the amount of interest actually paid. There will be no benefit if:

  • The balance of beneficial loans provided to a director or employee throughout 2021/22 does not exceed £10,000.
  • The loan is for a qualifying purpose, such as buying shares in a close company.

 

Directors should be particularly careful to not let an overdrawn current account go just over £10,000 at any point during the tax year.

Other uses

The official rate is also used in regard to employer-provided living accommodation and pre-owned assets tax (POAT).

  • Living accommodation – There is an additional benefit charge on the excess of the cost of the accommodation over £75,000. For example, if living accommodation cost £250,000, then the additional benefit charge for 2021/22 will be (£250,000 – £75,000) at 2% = £3,500.
  • POAT – There is an income tax charge on certain inheritance tax planning arrangements. Where chattels and intangible assets are concerned, the amount of deemed income subject to tax is the value of the asset multiplied by the official rate.

More detail on beneficial loans from an employer’s perspective can be found here.

 Photo by M. B. M. on Unsplash